Many people have criticized Jahn for his beliefs. He was known by many as a liberal figure, who advocated for a united Germany after the withdrawal of Napoleon's troops. He wanted to establish a democratic constitution, which would include the right to free speech. Peter Viereck claimed that Jahn was the spiritual founder of Nazism because of his belief that "Poles, French, priests, aristocrats and Jews are Germany's misfortune." Jacques Barzun observed that Viereck's claim was not supported by evidence. Alfred Baeumler wrote a monograph on Jahn in which he characterizes Jahn's invention of gymnastics as a political project designed to create the ultimate völkisch citizen by educating the body.
German Gymnastics uses a large fixed apparatus, vaulting, and marching. It had a "militaristic" view of fitness, with a strict, formal style to promote the Turnverein movement. Jahn believed this was the way to strengthen the German youth and make them strong citizens.
Swedish Gymnastics was founded by Pehr Henrik Ling. It was a health-oriented approach and was recognized for inherent medical values. Instead of using an apparatus, it focused on calisthenics and exercises. It was less strict than the German system and became popular in the United States because of Hartvig Nissen and Mils Posse.
Delsarte was a French system created by Francois Delsarte in the 1890s. This system focused on exercises that promoted poise, grace, beauty, and health. It was more beneficial for performances in singing, drama, and dance. It gained popularity in dance and theatre, and had limited and short-lived popularity in physical education.
Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Systemshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Ludwig_Jahn
No comments:
Post a Comment